Compare moats
Up to three covered companies, band by band. Every call is a curated editorial judgment, never a disclosed figure — and every band carries its cited basis.
| Tokyo Electron | Alibaba Group | |
|---|---|---|
| Moat rating | narrow Integrated Report 2026 (issued 2026-09-15) documents strong positions across the line: by Tokyo Electron's own estimate it ranks No. 1 in diffusion furnaces, batch deposition, metal deposition, coater/developers, gas chemical etch and wafer probers, No. 2 in plasma etch and bonders and No. 3 in cleaning, and holds a "100% share" of coater/developers for EUV lithography; its installed base, industry-leading by its own estimate, is approximately 100,000 units, growing by approximately 4,000-6,000 units a year; and its 26,592 patents rank No. 1 in the semiconductor production equipment industry on the LexisNexis PatentSight+ database. Reported returns stayed high through a sales decline: gross profit margin stayed between 44.6% and 47.1% and ROE between 21.8% and 37.2% across fiscal 2022-2026, including fiscal 2024 when net sales fell to ¥1,830.5 billion. The share ranks, the EUV share and the installed-base lead are company estimates, not third-party data. | wide The FY2026 20-F rests on two entrenched positions: a commerce ecosystem the filing ties to 'the world's largest online retail market' with 'over 1.1 billion Internet users,' and a cloud business whose 'Cloud Intelligence Group's external revenue growth accelerated to 40% in the final quarter of fiscal 2026, with AI-related products accounting for 30% of this revenue.' Two durable franchises under one roof is a wide moat — bounded by China regulation and US ICTS cloud controls the same filing flags. |
| Moat type | intangibles ip The report calls its patent portfolio its "fifth strength" and says that "by supporting our other four strengths, it serves a vital role as the foundation" for medium- to long-term corporate value: 26,592 patents as of March 31, 2026, 1,415 inventions created in Japan and 345 overseas in 2025, and Clarivate Top 100 Global Innovators recognition for the fifth consecutive year. The other strengths rest on the same proprietary process know-how — co-created technology roadmaps that evaluate technologies "for the next four generations and beyond" with customers, "numerous development PORs" (process of record) in the frontend business, and the EUV coater/developer position — so proprietary process technology, reinforced by qualification in customers' process flows, is the moat source. | network effects The 20-F names 'the network effects of our ecosystems' among the factors its business depends on: Taobao and Tmall, Alipay, Amap and the rest compound as buyers, sellers and services reinforce each other across one integrated ecosystem. |
| Leadership | co leader The CEO's message describes Tokyo Electron as "one of the world's leading suppliers of semiconductor production equipment" and states a "goal of becoming number one globally" — it does not claim to be the largest supplier overall — while by its own estimate it ranks No. 1 in six charted segments (diffusion furnace, batch deposition, metal deposition, coater/developer, gas chemical etch, wafer prober), No. 2 in plasma etch and bonders, and No. 3 in cleaning. | clear leader The 20-F claims leadership in applied AI ('strengthened our leadership in applied AI') and roots the commerce business in the world's largest online retail market; Alibaba Cloud is the leading China hyperscaler pivoting to AI, per the segment discussion — a category leader in both its home markets. |
| Pricing power | moderate Gross profit margin held in a 44.6%-47.1% range over fiscal 2022-2026, including fiscal 2024's sales decline, but in fiscal 2026 it fell 1.8 points to 45.3% "due to factors such as higher raw material prices and increased labor costs" even as net sales reached a record, and the CEO lists "revising prices appropriately with respect to cost increases caused by inflation" among five initiatives needed to improve the operating margin. | moderate Ecosystem lock-in and cloud scale support pricing, but the filing warns that if 'user activity and engagement in our ecosystem may decrease … our market share and profitability may be negatively affected,' and Chinese e-commerce/cloud competition is intense — real but capped pricing power. |
| Summary | Tokyo Electron makes wafer fab equipment for what its Integrated Report 2026 calls the "four key processes necessary for semiconductor scaling: deposition, coater/developer, etch, and cleaning", plus wafer probers and bonders for test and advanced packaging. The report grounds its edge in breadth and incumbency: leading share estimates in most of its segments, an estimated 100% share of EUV coater/developers, an installed base of approximately 100,000 units, industry-leading by its own estimate, feeding a Field Solutions business that sold ¥626.0 billion of parts, services, used equipment and modifications in fiscal 2026, and the industry's largest patent portfolio. Fiscal 2026 net sales were a record ¥2,443,533 million, but gross profit margin fell 1.8 points to 45.3% on higher raw material prices and labor costs, and operating margin fell 3.1 points to 25.6% as R&D expenses rose 11.1% to ¥277,866 million. China accounted for 34.1% of fiscal 2026 net sales, down from 41.7% the year before. | Alibaba is a commerce network and an AI cloud fused into one ecosystem. The retail side draws its moat from network effects the filing names explicitly, rooted in the world's largest online retail market; the cloud side is pivoting hard into AI — Alibaba Cloud's 'growth engine fully pivots from traditional compute and storage to models, AI compute, and agent services,' anchored by the in-house Qwen family (Qwen3.7-Max 'specifically engineered for agents') and the PAI platform. The 20-F's own framing is 'leading full-stack capabilities across the AI value chain.' The counterweights are structural rather than competitive: a Cayman VIE structure, China's regulatory environment, and the US Commerce Department's proposed ICTS cloud-computing controls the filing discloses. |
| Chain position | Upstream equipment supplier to chipmakers: fiscal 2026 new-equipment sales of ¥1,775.4 billion went 59% to non-memory (logic, foundry, others), 31% to DRAM and 10% to NAND; by region, China took 34.1%, South Korea 22.3% and Taiwan 20.4% of net sales. | Layer-8 hyperscaler + AI-application incumbent: Alibaba Cloud supplies AI compute and the Qwen models while the commerce ecosystem is a vast applied-AI distribution surface. |
| Products (share / barrier) |
|
|
| Long-horizon vote | +0.13 at weight 0.20 · swarm bearish Editorial prior, not backtested. | +0.38 at weight 0.20 · swarm neutral Editorial prior, not backtested. |