Compare moats
Up to three covered companies, band by band. Every call is a curated editorial judgment, never a disclosed figure — and every band carries its cited basis.
| United Microelectronics Corporation | Alibaba Group | Adobe | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moat rating | narrow The FY2025 20-F Competition section cuts both ways: UMC calls itself "one of the world's largest independent semiconductor foundries" with production capacity "currently among the largest of all semiconductor foundries in the world" and says it believes it competes favorably with competitors on each principal element of foundry competition, yet in the same section concedes that "[s]ome of our competitors have substantially greater production, financial, research and development and marketing resources than we have" and that "several new dedicated foundries have commenced operations and compete directly with us," whose entry is "likely to initiate a trend of competitive pricing and create potential overcapacity in legacy technology" that "may erode our profit margins." A real but bounded advantage, not a durable wide one. | wide The FY2026 20-F rests on two entrenched positions: a commerce ecosystem the filing ties to 'the world's largest online retail market' with 'over 1.1 billion Internet users,' and a cloud business whose 'Cloud Intelligence Group's external revenue growth accelerated to 40% in the final quarter of fiscal 2026, with AI-related products accounting for 30% of this revenue.' Two durable franchises under one roof is a wide moat — bounded by China regulation and US ICTS cloud controls the same filing flags. | narrow The FY2025 10-K's own Competition section says the markets for Adobe's solutions are characterized by 'limited barriers to entry, short product lifecycles, customer price sensitivity ... and the frequent entry of new solutions or competitors', and Item 1A adds that Adobe 'face[s] increasing competition from companies offering generative and agentic AI solutions, including but not limited to prompt-based and multi-modal creation and editing, document productivity and understanding' - the two categories that carry the Digital Media segment. That disclosed contestability caps the moat below wide, while the same filing's industry-standard app designations and 89% consolidated gross margin keep it well above none. |
| Moat type | intangibles ip The 20-F states plainly that "Our success depends on our ability to obtain patents, licenses and other intellectual property (IP) rights covering our production processes and activities," and reports more than 16,700 patents worldwide as of December 31, 2025, of which more than 7,490 are in the U.S., 623 domestic and foreign patents granted in 2025 alone, NT$17,725 million of R&D (7.5% of operating revenues) and 1,591 R&D professionals. The Competition section names where UMC believes it wins: it competes favorably "particularly [on] our technical competence and research and development capabilities." The proprietary specialty-process library, not scale or a network, is the cited source of the advantage. | network effects The 20-F names 'the network effects of our ecosystems' among the factors its business depends on: Taobao and Tmall, Alipay, Amap and the rest compound as buyers, sellers and services reinforce each other across one integrated ecosystem. | switching costs The 10-K frames Adobe's differentiation as an integrated ecosystem the customer's work lives inside: Creative Cloud Pro subscribers get 'cloud storage to easily sync, access, collaborate and share their work, files and assets', the AI platform offers a choice of models 'without the friction of switching between workflows and platforms', and on the enterprise side 'Our competitive differentiation comes from the increased value we provide customers by integrating the Adobe Experience Platform with our comprehensive set of solutions'. 96% of FY2025 revenue is subscription, with $22.52B of remaining performance obligations, up 13% year over year. |
| Leadership | fast follower UMC describes a deliberate follow strategy in the 20-F: it intends "to avoid investments in technologies that do not present commercial potential for volume production" and believes "it is beneficial to defer investment in premature equipment needed to claim the earliest advanced technology and instead to purchase more advanced and less expensive versions of such equipment from vendors who design this equipment based on pre-production lessons learned from the earliest technology." The node ladder bears this out: the most advanced process in production in 2025 is Fab 12A's 0.014 micron, wafers at 14 nanometers and under rounded to 0.0% of wafer sales in each of 2023, 2024 and 2025, and the next rung — UMC's own 12nm FinFET process, which Intel replicated in 2025 "based on our electrical design rules and UMC-verified process" for manufacture at its Arizona fab — is only "expected to begin in 2027." | clear leader The 20-F claims leadership in applied AI ('strengthened our leadership in applied AI') and roots the commerce business in the world's largest online retail market; Alibaba Cloud is the leading China hyperscaler pivoting to AI, per the segment discussion — a category leader in both its home markets. | clear leader In the segment that is 74% of FY2025 revenue ($17.65B of $23.77B) the 10-K asserts leadership outright: Illustrator 'our industry-standard vector graphics app', After Effects 'our industry-standard motion graphics and visual effects app', Acrobat 'a leading document productivity app', and 'category and brand leadership' in the Competition section. The claim does not extend to the whole company - the same section says the marketing solutions 'face broad competition from large, established enterprise software and cloud companies'. |
| Pricing power | weak The 20-F claims no premium — "our current level of pricing is comparable to that of other leading foundries in each respective geometry" — and reports that 2025 average selling price declined 5.4%, driving gross margin down from 32.6% in 2024 to 29.0% in 2025 even as 12-inch-equivalent wafer shipments rose from 3,446 thousand to 3,870 thousand and average capacity utilization improved from 68.7% to 75.2%. It also notes that "[p]rices for wafers of a given level of technology generally decline over the processing technology life cycle." | moderate Ecosystem lock-in and cloud scale support pricing, but the filing warns that if 'user activity and engagement in our ecosystem may decrease … our market share and profitability may be negatively affected,' and Chinese e-commerce/cloud competition is intense — real but capped pricing power. | strong Per the same 10-K's segment table, Digital Media earned a 95% gross profit margin in FY2025 (96% FY2024, 95% FY2023) and consolidated gross margin held at 88%/89%/89% across FY2023-FY2025 while revenue grew 11% to $23.77B. 96% of revenue is subscription and remaining performance obligations reached $22.52B, up 13%. Item 1A's warning of 'downward pressure on pricing and gross margins' has not shown up in realized margin. |
| Summary | UMC's durable asset is a proprietary mature- and specialty-node process library — 55/40/28/22nm embedded memory for MCU and automotive, 55/40/28/22/14nm embedded high-voltage for display drivers, 110/55nm BCD for power management, 55/28/22nm BSI-CSI for image sensors and 110/90/55/40nm RF-SOI — backed by more than 16,700 patents worldwide at end-2025 and 7.5% of revenue spent on R&D. That library keeps a concentrated customer base qualified into UMC's fabs (top ten customers were 57.0% of 2025 operating revenues; Texas Instruments, Intel, MediaTek, Realtek and Novatek are named as primary customers). What it does not buy is price: 2025 average selling price fell 5.4% and gross margin fell from 32.6% to 29.0%, while the filing warns that new dedicated foundries are likely to initiate competitive pricing and overcapacity in legacy technology. | Alibaba is a commerce network and an AI cloud fused into one ecosystem. The retail side draws its moat from network effects the filing names explicitly, rooted in the world's largest online retail market; the cloud side is pivoting hard into AI — Alibaba Cloud's 'growth engine fully pivots from traditional compute and storage to models, AI compute, and agent services,' anchored by the in-house Qwen family (Qwen3.7-Max 'specifically engineered for agents') and the PAI platform. The 20-F's own framing is 'leading full-stack capabilities across the AI value chain.' The counterweights are structural rather than competitive: a Cayman VIE structure, China's regulatory environment, and the US Commerce Department's proposed ICTS cloud-computing controls the filing discloses. | Adobe's durable advantage is the cost of leaving rather than any disclosed market share. Its FY2025 10-K calls Illustrator 'our industry-standard vector graphics app' and After Effects 'our industry-standard motion graphics and visual effects app', describes Acrobat as 'a leading document productivity app', and sells them as one subscription ecosystem where assets, workflows and collaboration are cloud-resident. The economics follow: Digital Media earned a 95% gross profit margin on $17.65B of FY2025 revenue, 74% of the company. The same filing is unusually candid about the limits, calling its markets characterized by 'limited barriers to entry' and warning that competition will 'continue to intensify' with named generative and agentic AI entrants in both creation and document productivity - so the moat reads narrow rather than wide, held today by realized pricing and switching costs rather than by structural protection. |
| Chain position | Mature- and specialty-node wafer supplier: 2025 wafer sales were 41.4% communication, 30.6% consumer and 11.6% computer, with the AI tie indirect — 2.5D silicon interposers with deep-trench capacitors shipped to major customers for HPC, cloud computing and LLM applications. | Layer-8 hyperscaler + AI-application incumbent: Alibaba Cloud supplies AI compute and the Qwen models while the commerce ecosystem is a vast applied-AI distribution surface. | An AI-application layer company that both builds its own commercially safe Firefly foundation models and licenses 'an extensive ecosystem of third-party models', distributing generative AI into creative, document and marketing workflows. |
| Products (share / barrier) |
|
|
|
| Long-horizon vote | -0.01 at weight 0.20 · swarm neutral Editorial prior, not backtested. | +0.38 at weight 0.20 · swarm neutral Editorial prior, not backtested. | +0.24 at weight 0.20 · swarm neutral Editorial prior, not backtested. |